In June 2025 the York & North Yorkshire Combined Authority was given a grant to perform a pilot for rural bus franchising across the county. The pilot was split into 5 pilot areas. Whitby was included in the area known as “North York Moors” – see map below (the purple area).
We were invited to take part as a stakeholder in 2 workshops for the “North York Moors” pilot area. We provided a thorough list of the problem areas, including many parts of Whitby with no bus service, infrequent bus service to other parts of Whitby, nearby villages with no service, no direct link to any hospital, long journeys to get to many destinations, and so on … as per our “Public Transport” page.
As a result of input from all stakeholders, a draft report is now published, including proposals for each of the 5 pilot areas, together with recommendations on how the bus service improvements should be taken forward (e.g using a franchising model as one example).Â
If we go directly to the section for the “North York Moors” area we find the local objectives as
- To provide an attractive bus network that people can have confidence in, offering improved levels of regular services that link places within and beyond the area and that meets the needs of both residents and visitors, and for staff working at visitor attractions and in hospitality.
- To provide a bus network that maximises travel options and connectivity through the offer of connecting services and interchange.
- To enhance infrastructure and information provision to encourage greater use of the bus network.
We then look at the proposals for improvement in our district. The first level proposals include
- Arriva X93 – later evening departures (in Summer) from Whitby back to Middlesbrough and earlier journeys in the morning towards Middlesbrough.
- Coastliner 840 – enhance Whitby – Pickering – Malton section of route with earlier and later arrivals into, and departures from, Whitby.
- Moorsbus – Introduce some shuttle services on summer weekdays within the National Park connecting with core bus services at hubs, such as Pickering and Kirkbymoorside (e.g. linking to Castle Howard and Rievaulx Abbey).
- Coordinate timetables to achieve North-South/East-West connections at Pickering.
- Provide local town bus within Whitby.
- Improve passenger waiting infrastructure at Pickering, with suitable space for connecting buses.
- Improve information provision at stops.
The second level proposals include
- Enhance Coastliner 840 Whitby – Pickering to hourly.
- Demand responsive transport feeders to link with core bus and rail services, including Esk Valley Line.
Our Comments on the Proposals
The first thing to say is that, given the many problems with the public transport network and options in this district, we welcome any improvement. Having earlier / later services on the X93/X94 will make the bus a viable option for some people. Similarly earlier / later services on the 840 Coastliner, though this route is largely a tourist service. A broader schedule for Moorsbus would be of benefit up the Esk Valley, even though the services are only proposed during the summer schedule. Regarding the “local town bus for Whitby”, they presumably mean taking the Arriva 95 service and changing the route to include the whole of the town – that would be of benefit to those parts of the town with no option currently. Regarding having an interchange at Pickering, whilst that may help for some services, having an interchange at Malton to swap to the rail service would be better.
On the negative side
- Journey times have not been addressed. The time taken to reach a destination by public transport has to be reasonable enough when compared to the journey time in a private car to make people want to use it.
- The Whitby to Scarborough route journey time (1 hour+) is not going to motivate many people to leave their vehicle behind, and we would have hoped for a fast(er) service aligned with the rail timetable from Scarborough.
- The 840 Coastliner service takes 2.5 hours to reach York. There is nothing proposed to change that. So having it every hour, without addressing journey time, is peculiar.
- The report states that there is an Arriva bus depot in Redcar (serving this area). This is actually closed.
- The lack of services to any hospital has not been addressed. There is a proposal for more frequent services to Scarborough Hospital, which is a minor plus, but nothing on connectivity to other hospitals. Saying that services will be better integrated may reduce journey time for some hospitals, but until there is a list of how a patient from Whitby district would get to James Cook, Friarage, York, Malton, Bridlington, Scarborough (and Whitby) hospitals, the issue will remain. Perhaps Whitby hospital could be included on a “Whitby town bus”?Â
If we then look at the proposals for all areas to put the North York Moors area in contrast. In many other pilot areas there is significantly more detail on the proposals. There is a potential routing for a Scarborough town bus, with key destinations listed, but nothing provided for the Whitby option.
The current levels of subsidy, per area is as follows
- “York-Selby” receives £1m+;
- “Coastal Communities and Vale of Pickering” receives £850k+ – with a resident population of around 94000;
- “Yorkshire Dales” receives £1.25m+ – with a resident population of around 23000;
- “Richmond, Northallerton and Ripon” receives £2.5m+ – with a resident population of 62000+;
- “North York Moors” receives around £230k – with a resident population of around 23500.
Then we look at spend for the proposals.
- “Coastal Communities and Vale of Pickering (inc Scarborough, Filey)” would need £8.9m;
- “Richmond, Northallerton and Ripon” would need £8.5m;
- “Yorkshire Dales” would need £9.2m;
- “York-Selby” would need £4.9m;
- “North York Moors (inc Whitby)” would need £3.3m.
There are high levels of deprivation that are significant in many parts of Whitby and surrounding area, together with high levels of transport poverty. The baseline public transport offering right now is poor and not meeting the needs of many people. Even the Y&NY Mayor has stated that coastal communities suffer from inadequate transport connections and need better access to public transport, employment, education and services.Â
As a overall assessment, compared to what is proposed elsewhere, we can only describe the current proposals as disappointing.
Whether they will change before allocation of investment remains to be seen.

